I used to be an athlete (or a dancer). Why can't I get my strength back after 40?
Because for years, your sport did the thinking for you. A coach, a team, a schedule and a season told you exactly how to train. Take that away, add kids, a career and perimenopause, and your body loses the signal. The athlete is still in there. She needs a real training plan and a coach again.
You didn't lose it.
You lost the structure around it.
Why does this feel so frustrating when you used to be so strong?
Because you know exactly what strong felt like.
A lot of the women we talk to played soccer or volleyball, swam, skated, skied or danced for years. Some competed at a high level. They tell us they were naturally fit for a very long time, until they weren't.
Here's the part that stings.
Most of them say they never really "worked out." They played. The sport kept them strong, and nobody ever had to teach them how to train on their own.
So when the sport ended, the plan ended with it.
What actually changed?
Usually a few things at once:
- The structure disappeared. No coach, no practice schedule, no season with a goal at the end.
- Life took over. Kids, a career, years of putting everyone else first. An injury that set you back and never quite got rehabbed.
- Muscle drifted. In our experience, a few years without real strength work adds up, and muscle is what keeps your metabolism working for you. Chris puts it simply: "Muscle is metabolism."
- Perimenopause changed the rules. The body that used to respond to anything now needs a much clearer signal.
None of that erases what you built. It just means the old approach needs updating.
Why isn't going harder working?
Because "harder" usually means more of the wrong thing.
Former athletes are tough. When something stops working, they push. More spin classes. More miles. A different class every day.
Chris has a name for that: a "vomit of exercise." Lots of sweat, mixed messages, no direction. Your body has no idea what you want it to become.
Your sport never trained you that way. Every practice built on the last one. That's progressive overload, and it's the piece most adult workouts are missing.
If you've been running or spinning your way to nowhere, read is cardio making perimenopause fat loss harder.
And if you lifted heavy in college and came away worried about your legs, you're not the only one. Here's why lifting won't make you bulky now.
What does training like an athlete look like after 40?
Pretty familiar, actually.
- A plan with a purpose. Four strength workouts a week, about 50 minutes each, at home with a set of dumbbells and your own bodyweight. Each one builds on the last.
- A coach watching your form. Chris has coached professional athletes for decades. He coaches every move in our workouts, with easier and harder options.
- Fuel for performance. Enough food to train on and recover from. Under-eating was never part of an athlete's plan.
- A check-in every week. Your coach looks at your week and adjusts the plan, the way a good coach always did.
Got an old injury? Work around it with your coach. Check with your doctor or physio first, then read can I still strength train with a bad knee, shoulder or back.
What about losing the weight?
Most women come to us wanting to lose weight. What they actually want to lose is fat.
For a former athlete, that switch usually clicks fast. You already know the scale was never the point. Strong, lean and capable was.
We've helped 1,000+ women lose 10 to 20 lbs of fat in 8 weeks, while they build the strength back.
Will I ever feel like an athlete again?
Here's the thing.
Your body remembers how to be coached. A lot of the women with a sports background tell us the training feels familiar within a few weeks. The discipline, the body awareness, showing up when it's hard. That's all still there.
What feeling like an athlete again looks like for the women we coach:
- The weights go up. Week by week, on purpose.
- Your energy comes back. Enough to get through the day and still have something left.
- You get back to your game. Tennis, pickleball, a pickup volleyball league, skiing with your kids.
If you still play, read can I keep playing tennis or pickleball and strength train.
Ashley's story
At 44, with a demanding career and three kids, Ashley was running and eating well, and nothing was working anymore. She shares what changed.
Ready to train like an athlete again?
Start with the short video on our homepage at fortyfwd.com. It walks through why your body stopped responding after 40 and the method we use to change that.
If it sounds like you, apply for a call with Chris.
He reads every application himself. On the call, he'll look at where you're starting, what you used to do and what you want back, and tell you straight whether the program is the right fit. If it is, he walks you through the investment then, once you both know it's a fit.
You already know how to be coached.
Let's put you back on the team.
Frequently asked questions
I used to be an athlete. Why can't I lose weight now?
Usually because the structure your sport gave you is gone, years of life have let muscle drift, and perimenopause changed what your body responds to. A progressive strength plan, enough food and a coach tend to bring it back.
Is it too late to get my strength back after 40?
No. In our experience, women with a sports or dance background often find the training familiar within a few weeks, and the weights go up steadily from there.
Should I just go back to running or classes harder?
More of the same usually leaves former athletes tired and stuck. What works is a structured strength plan that builds week to week, with your walks and your sport around it.
I lifted heavy in college and my legs got big. Will that happen again?
Your coach builds the plan around your goals, and after 40 strength training mostly changes shape and strength. Lean, strong and capable is the target.
Can I keep playing my sport while I do this?
Yes. Your coach plans your strength work around tennis, pickleball, skiing or whatever you play, so the two help each other.
More answers: Strength training and exercise
- I've never lifted weights and I'm scared I'm doing it wrong. Can I really do this at home?
- What equipment do I need to strength train at home, and can I do the workouts at my gym instead?
- How many days a week should a woman over 40 strength train, and how long should workouts be?
- Do I have to quit my fitness classes or my trainer to do strength training?