Am I eating too little? I barely eat and still can't lose fat.

Very possibly, yes. When you eat too little for long enough, your body tends to read it as a threat instead of a signal to burn fat. In our experience, it slows down, holds on to fat and gives up muscle. A lot of the women we coach lose fat once they start eating more, with protein at every meal.

Here's the thing.

Your body needs fuel to change.

And eating enough is a lot less scary than it sounds.

Why can't I lose fat when I barely eat?

Because "eat less, move more" stopped working for most of us a long time ago.

When you eat too little, your body doesn't read it as a signal to burn fat. It reads it as a threat. It thinks food is scarce, so it does exactly what it's designed to do. It protects you.

In our experience, that looks like this:

• Your metabolism slows down to save what it has.
• Your body holds on to fat like an emergency fund.
• It gives up muscle, the exact thing you need to burn fat and change your shape.

Chris puts it in three words: "Muscle is metabolism."

Lose muscle, and the next round of cutting back tends to be even harder than the last.

I know this one firsthand. In my early 30s, I was barely eating, going to bed late and waking up super early. Chris taught me how to fuel my body, and for the first time in years, my body started responding. Then in my 40s, I started gaining anyway, and I pushed harder. More workouts, more restrictions, more effort. It made things worse.

If the change is showing up around your middle, here's why belly fat shows up in perimenopause even when nothing else changed.

How do I know if I'm eating too little?

Most women who under-eat have no idea they're doing it. It just feels like being "good."

A lot of the women we talk to tell us some version of this: "I barely eat, and I'm still gaining."

Here are the signs our coaches look for:

• Coffee is breakfast. Your first real food shows up at lunch, or later. Can we please stop pretending a latte counts as a meal?
• You're starving by 4 o'clock. Then the afternoon snacking starts, or the pantry raid at night.
• You're tired all the time. Even when you sleep. Here's why that happens in perimenopause.
• Your workouts feel flat. You keep showing up, and you're not getting any stronger.
• You barely feel hungry anymore. In our experience, that's often a body that has gotten used to running low.

Two or more sound familiar? You're in very good company.

One gentle note. If food has felt hard in a bigger way, or you have a history of an eating disorder, please talk to your doctor first. Some women need more support than a web page can give, and that's okay.

Why does eating more feel so scary?

Because we were all raised on the same rule. Eat less, move more.

And maybe back in your 20s, it even worked.

So the fear makes total sense:

• "What if I gain?" You fought for every pound you lost. Adding food feels like undoing it.
• "Cutting back is the only thing that's ever worked." A lot of women tell us the extreme version worked once. They just couldn't live on it.
• "I don't know what enough looks like." After years of shrinking your plate, a normal one can look huge.
• "I'll lose control." If you open the door to more food, will it ever close?

Here's what I'd tell you over coffee.

Chris says it best: "You're not failing. The system you were running was not the right system for you."

Eating more, the way we coach it, means eating on purpose. With a plan, and a coach watching how your body responds.

What does "eating enough" actually look like?

Simpler than you think.

Here's how we build it with the women we coach:

• Protein at every meal. Eggs, Greek yogurt, chicken, fish, cottage cheese, last night's leftovers. In our experience, it's the piece most women are missing, and it's what helps your body hold on to muscle while you lose fat.
• 4 to 5 eating opportunities a day. Meals plus a snack or two, so you never hit 4 o'clock running on empty.
• Real food, carbs included. The first 14 days are lower carb and higher protein, with a short break from alcohol, dairy, gluten and processed sugar. Then foods come back. Sweet potato, quinoa, sourdough, a banana with your snack.
• Fuel before you train. We usually steer women away from working out on an empty stomach.
• No counting. No calorie counting, no food scales, no tracking macros. Your coach builds the plan around your schedule and the foods you enjoy, so you never have to do the math.

One thing our coaches watch closely.

Some women hold on to that lower-carb, eat-less mindset long after day 14. That's usually when things stall again. When the carbs come back, let them.

Most women come to us wanting to lose weight. What they actually want to lose is fat. And in our experience, fat loss goes a lot better in a body that's actually fuelled.

Working out hard on top of barely eating? Read the three things we check first.

What happens when I start eating more?

Honestly? It feels strange for a week or two.

Then most women wonder why they waited.

Here's what we usually see:

• Energy shows up first. For a lot of women, it's the first thing they notice.
• The 4 o'clock crash gets quieter. And the late-night pantry visits tend to follow.
• Your workouts get stronger. Your body finally has something to build with.
• The scale might wiggle. More food means a little more food and water in your system for a few days. That's usually water, and it settles.
• Your clothes start telling the story. Body composition changes often show up in your waistband before the scale catches up.

And you won't be guessing. Your coach checks in every week and adjusts the plan as your body responds.

We've helped 1,000+ women lose 10 to 20 lbs of fat in 8 weeks. Plenty of them were eating more by the end than when they started.

Franny started eating more

I sat down with Franny, a busy mom and executive, about how she got out of the restrictive-diet cycle and started eating more, all while working full-time and travelling.

Skipping breakfast on purpose? Read is intermittent fasting good in perimenopause.

Ready to stop running on empty?

You've been trying so hard, for so long.

Let's put that effort into something that works.

Start with the short video on our homepage at fortyfwd.com. It walks through why your body stopped responding after 40 and the method we use to change that.

If it sounds like you, apply for a call with Chris.

He reads every application himself. On the call, he'll look at how you're eating right now and tell you straight whether the program is the right fit. If it is, he walks you through the investment then, once you both know it's a fit.

Your body has been asking for enough for a long time.

Let's give it what it needs.

Frequently asked questions

Why am I not losing weight when I barely eat?

When you eat too little for a long stretch, your body tends to read it as a threat. In our experience, it slows down, holds on to fat and gives up muscle, which makes fat loss harder.

How do I know if I'm eating too little?

Common signs we see: coffee instead of breakfast, starving by 4 o'clock, tired even when you sleep, flat workouts, and barely feeling hungry at all. Two or more is worth a closer look.

Will eating more make me gain weight?

In our experience, moving from barely eating to eating enough, with protein at every meal and strength training, is usually when fat loss starts moving again. The scale can wiggle for a few days from extra food and water, then it settles.

How often should I eat to lose fat after 40?

We build most plans around 4 to 5 eating opportunities a day, with protein at every one. That way you never hit the afternoon running on empty.

Do I have to count calories to make sure I'm eating enough?

No. There's no calorie counting, no food scales and no tracking macros. Your coach builds the plan around your schedule and the foods you enjoy, so you never have to do the math.

More answers: Food and nutrition

• I eat clean all day and then raid the pantry at 8pm. Why, and how do I stop?
• Is intermittent fasting good for women in perimenopause? I'm never hungry in the morning.
• Should I eat before a morning workout, or is it better to train on an empty stomach?
• Can I still drink wine, eat with my family and keep my favourite foods and still lose fat?

Browse every answer on Ask Elle